Beginning readers often substitute their own words for those in print.
While we want readers to eventually become accurate readers, that should
not be the primary goal. Making sense and getting meaning from the text
is more important.
Even expert readers sometimes make errors or substitutions in the
text without realizing it. Unless those substitutions change the meaning,
you don't have to worry about them. Instead of calling them mistakes
or errors, we call them Miscues. A miscue is any deviation from the
text.
Some things for you to keep in mind:
- If a miscue doesn't change the meaning, or changes it only slightly,
you can ignore it. "He rode his bike in/on the road."
- Try not to jump in too quickly; wait and give the reader a chance
to self-correct or problem solve.
- Show confidence in the child's ability and be available to help.
Some things readers can be encouraged to do when they are trying
to figure out a word or get stuck:
PICTURE PROMPT: Direct reader to look at the picture, or to close
eyes and imagine what is happening.
RERUN: Suggest rereading the sentence or phrase to clarify the meaning
so far. This can help in predicting the upcoming word, giving the reader
more time to access it.
CONTEXT PROMPT: Ask the reader if what he or she just read made sense;
use this information to help the reader predict what words would "make
sense" or "sound right" in a sentence. Then help the
reader check the print to confirm the prediction.
READ-ON: Beginning readers can be encouraged to skip over the unknown
word and read to the end of the phrase or sentence, substituting a grunt
in place of the mystery word. "I never ['mmm'] what to give my
mother for her birthday. " This helps readers use the meaning (context)
of the surrounding words, and sometimes the initial letter(s) to figure
out the problem word.
COMPARING: Ask if reader has seen a word that looks like the troubling
one; or write a similar word, i.e. if the hard word is "fright",
point out or write down "night. " (Be sure to use a word that
you are sure the child will recognize.) Helping the child see that a
word part is similar to another known word can help too. A fluent reader
can think "If I know 'her' and 'taps,' I can figure out 'perhaps'"
(assuming she or he has heard and understands the word).
STRUCTURAL PROMPT: Tell or ask the child to notice the word's parts:
play-ing; out-side. Help the reader cover the appropriate part of the
word.
LOOK BACK TO PREVIOUS CONTEXT: Sometimes beginning readers recognize
that they've seen a word somewhere else. Looking back or identifying
the former context can help the reader recall the word.
After the student figures out a difficult word, or after he or she
self corrects, be sure to encourage him or her to ask: "Does this
make sense? Does this sound right? Does this look right?" Once
the child is satisfied that the sentence does make sense, give specific
praise for using good strategies to figure out words. Encouraging students
to constantly ask themselves "Does this make sense?" when
reading reinforces the purpose of reading: we read to understand the
meaning of the text, not simply to translate the printed letters into
spoken words.