Children’s Book Committee

Young Reviewers Program

The Young Reviewers Program includes children—from toddlers through high school students—who read and review books that are currently being considered by the Children’s Book Committee (CBC) for our Best Children’s Books of the Year list and Children’s Book Awards. Some Young Reviewers have been in the program for years and many have highlighted their experience on school and scholarship résumés.

Started more than 20 years ago, the program supports the CBC’s longstanding mission to evaluate books for children, parents, librarians, and educators by focusing on how books can affect young readers. Members of the CBC have a wide range of experience in the world of education, writing, and book publishing, but the voices of children through the Young Reviewers Program provide the committee with valuable insights into the literature we read throughout each year. Reviews are shared with committee members at weekly meetings and, at the end of the year, the CBC will consider many criteria when compiling the Best Children’s Books of the Year List, including the thoughts of our Young Reviewers. Excerpts from some reviews are shared on social media and at our awards ceremony in the spring.

For more information about our program, please email youngreviewers@bankstreet.edu.


Children's Book Committee July Pick

Between Two Brothers
Author: Crystal Allen

When his beloved older brother suffers a brain injury in a car accident, Isaiah (Ice) defies dire predictions and devises ways to help him recover. Back matter.

Our Young Reviewer Says:

“I liked the inspiration in this book. I found the story to be somewhat relatable, and something that could happen in real life. Although it would be a rare occurrence, the author made you feel like it was truly happening to you.

The book was told through the main characters point of view, who was the younger brother of Seth, who suffered the traumatic brain injury. Although he was 18 and successful, the doctors told the family he had coherency of a seven-month-old baby. Isaiah, the main character was also going through his own struggles, crippling social anxiety. The author brought us through what it is like to live with this horrible anxiety, but also growing, and changing, because all of the sudden Isaiah, the younger brother had to deal with becoming the older brother, taking a lot of responsibility. The author did a wonderful job of expressing the pain, and success the family felt, and dealt with, during this horrendous time.”

–Luci, age 14, San Rafael, CA.

Past Monthly Picks